ASTM D638-22 and D790-25: How to Check Export Test Reports
Both reports cite ASTM, but specimens, procedures and modulus methods follow different rules
Why export projects ask for both reports
Owners, engineering firms and third-party laboratories in North America most often cite ASTM D638 for the tensile properties of plastics and reinforced plastics, and ASTM D790 for flexural properties. Grating walkway panels are deflection-controlled, so flexural modulus feeds straight into the span calculation; tensile data serves material verification and tension-side checks.
Both reports carry an ASTM number, but the rules behind them are entirely different. Accepting data because it says “tested to ASTM” easily puts results from different specimens, speeds and procedures side by side.
D638-22: identify the specimen type first
The current edition is ASTM D638-22, approved and published in July 2022 and superseding D638-14. It covers unreinforced and reinforced plastics up to about 14 mm thick, is maintained by ASTM Committee D20 on plastics, and can determine Poisson's ratio.
| Specimen | Typical use |
|---|---|
| Type I | Preferred for rigid and semi-rigid plastics; about 50 mm gauge length, 165 mm overall, 3.2 mm thick |
| Type II | Alternative when a rigid material fails outside the Type I gauge section |
| Type III | Thicker material, about 7–14 mm |
| Type IV | Flexible or non-rigid plastics, up to about 4 mm thick |
| Type V | Miniature specimen, about 25 mm gauge, for limited material or environmental chambers |
Cast resin samples for grating usually use Type I; thin sections cut from molded grating may use Type IV; thick profiles or special sampling use Type III. The wrong specimen can change the strength value substantially, so the report must state the type.
D638-22: speed sets the number
D638 selects the lowest speed in its table that ruptures the specimen in 0.5–5 minutes, unless a material specification says otherwise. For Types I–IV, rigid materials commonly run at 5 mm/min, ductile materials at 50 mm/min, and non-rigid materials up to 500 mm/min; Type V uses 1, 10 or 100 mm/min.
Strength and elongation change with speed, so reports must be aligned on speed before being compared. A report that gives strength but not speed cannot be verified.
For one batch of material, a report at 5 mm/min and another at 50 mm/min cannot be averaged or mined for the higher value. The speed cited in the design document is the speed acceptance should use.
One difference is easily missed: D638 measures tensile modulus at the same speed as the other properties, while ISO 527 normally uses a separate 1 mm/min modulus test. Both require an extensometer, and D638 specifies its accuracy class. This is one reason the same material can show slightly different modulus in D638 and ISO 527 reports.
D790-25: identify the procedure first
The current edition is ASTM D790-25, published on 1 December 2025 and superseding D790-17. Its title is Standard Test Methods for Flexural Properties of Unreinforced and Reinforced Plastics and Electrical Insulating Materials; the method is a simply supported beam under three-point loading for rigid and semi-rigid materials. Four-point bending is covered separately by ASTM D6272, which parallels ISO 178 but differs in technical detail.
D790 defines the test condition by the ratio of support span to specimen depth: Procedure A is normally 16:1 and Procedure B is 32:1. A shorter span makes interlaminar shear more likely; a longer span lowers the bending stress and increases deflection. Strengths from the two procedures are not directly comparable, and the report must state which was used.
The familiar specimen is about 127 mm × 12.7 mm × 3.2 mm, but the standard allows adjustment for material thickness. When sampling a grating profile, the specimen thickness is often the product wall thickness, which makes it even more important to report the actual dimensions.
D790-25: strength, modulus and correction
Flexural strength is the maximum outer-fibre stress before failure. If the specimen neither breaks nor yields within 5.0% outer-fibre strain, the standard says flexural strength cannot be reported; a “strength” appearing in such a report either comes from another method or needs an explanation of how it was handled.
Flexural modulus comes from the initial linear portion of the load–deflection curve. Deflection may be measured by crosshead displacement or by a deflectometer, the two give different results, and the report must say which was used; at larger deflections the standard requires a large-deflection correction, and the report should state whether it was applied.
A report that gives flexural strength but not flexural modulus leaves the deflection calculation without an input; a report with modulus but no strength cannot check ultimate capacity. A complete flexural report gives both, with the conditions for each.
Grating load tables are usually published for uniform load at a specified deflection limit. A modulus measured by D790 Procedure A cannot simply be applied to data measured by Procedure B or GB/T 1449. Span ratio, specimen orientation and fibre content all change the modulus, and there is no universal conversion factor between standards.
Why the moduli in the two reports disagree
Tensile modulus and flexural modulus are not the same quantity. A tensile test measures the response of the material along its axis; a flexural test measures the response of a section under bending. The two moduli of one material are close but not equivalent, and one cannot be substituted into a calculation written for the other.
Even between flexural moduli, D790 and GB/T 1449 use different specimens and span ratios, so the values are not interchangeable; even between tensile moduli, D638 and ISO 527 measure at different speeds, so the reported values may differ. When two reports disagree, check method and conditions first, then decide which set applies to the project.
To decide which set applies, check which method the design document cites: a span calculation designed to D790 uses the D790 modulus, and verification to GB/T 1449 is compared on GB/T 1449 conditions. Averaging the moduli from two reports does not produce a more reliable value.
Report checklist for export projects
When a tensile or flexural report arrives for a North American project, check the following:
- Standard and edition: D638-22 or D790-25, not a vague “D638” or “D790”.
- Specimen type (D638) or procedure (D790).
- Specimen dimensions, sampling direction and conditioning.
- Test speed (D638) or span ratio (D790).
- Failure mode and failure location.
- How modulus was measured: extensometer, crosshead displacement or deflectometer.
- Whether the large-deflection correction was applied to a flexural report.
A report with missing items is not automatically unusable, but the laboratory has to be asked. Citing the edition in the purchasing document stops the laboratory from using an older edition or choosing the procedure on its own.
The exception for continuous-fibre profiles
D638 is a suitable method for molded grating, grating resins and short-fibre reinforced parts. For axial tensile testing of continuous-fibre pultruded profiles, the industry more often uses a method such as ASTM D3039, written for continuous-fibre composites; if a customer specifies D638, the report should state the sampling direction and its applicability.
D3039 and D638 use different specimens and gripping, so the two reports cannot be converted into each other; when a customer requires both, sample and report them separately and state the material direction each one represents.
Whichever method is used, transverse tensile strength is usually much lower than longitudinal and must be tested separately. Substituting longitudinal data for a transverse check, like substituting tensile modulus for flexural modulus, makes the calculation optimistic.
Source text and further reading
The official entries are in the Niteck FRP grating standards library. For the load data North American projects usually ask for, see FRP grating load capacity; for specifications and tolerances, see FRP grating specifications, for checking against project conditions.
Where a project cites both GB/T and ASTM methods, the purchasing document should state which one governs acceptance, so a disagreement between the two reports does not leave the decision open.
Purchasing and testing contracts should state the standard edition, the specimen type or procedure, and whether longitudinal and transverse data are both required. Writing only “to ASTM” lets the laboratory choose, and the resulting report may not be usable directly for design.
This article explains the methods and does not replace the standard text; the current editions govern all test conditions and criteria.
简体中文
English